The High-ROI Membership Growth Strategy Most Credit Unions Overlook
We know that credit unions pride themselves on their exceptional member service. But you can't just tell prospective members that your service is exceptional. You need to show them by letting your members do the talking.
We're willing to bet that your credit union has a lot of happy members who aren't doing the talking for one simple reason: You haven't asked them to. After all, leaving reviews online isn't always easy or intuitive, and passive strategies disproportionately capture the most frustrated voices.
In this episode of the Remarkable Credit Union Podcast, we sit down with Heather Snyder, VP of Marketing and Community Development at Fiber Federal Credit Union, to explore how Fiber Federal created and executed a proactive, intentional, and highly successful reputation management strategy.
Tune in to discover how this strategy has driven membership growth, boosted staff morale, inspired award-winning marketing campaigns, and even led to an entirely unexpected twist involving a killer clown. We also tackle this month's BIG question:
Why should member reviews be a critical focus for credit unions, and what is the danger of failing to build a strategy around reputation management?
Key takeaways:
- A proactive reputation management strategy is low-hanging fruit with a high ROI. No matter how exceptional your member service is, most members are unlikely to leave a review unless explicitly asked. By actively soliciting Google reviews, Fiber Federal Credit Union saw their average rating jump from 3.39 to 4.65 across 20 locations, significantly outperforming local competitors in both review volume and search visibility.
- Empowering frontline employees to request reviews improves team morale. Member reviews help make frontline employees’ vital contributions visible across the credit union, and they also help to engage and reward member-facing staff.
- Member reviews can be leveraged far beyond Google. Positive member reviews can be repurposed in many creative ways. Fibre Federal creatively leveraged their review repository to create award-winning video advertising campaigns. Not only were the videos highly entertaining, but authentic testimonials from members are hard to beat.
Resources & links:
- Fibre Federal Credit Union: The credit union where guest Heather Snyder serves as VP of Marketing and Community Development.
- Fibre Federal's award-winning video campaign: The campaign that leveraged the talents of a voice actor and Fibre Federal's hundreds of positive member reviews.
- Eltropy: The text provider for Fibre Federal's text-based, employee-initiated Google review solicitation strategy.
- Reviews Up: A third-party service retained by Fiber Federal to manage timely review responses and offer an alternative review option for non-Google users.
- MAC (Marketing Association of Credit Unions): The organization hosting the MAC Conference where Fiber Federal presented their video campaign as a runner-up for the prestigious MACQUEE Award.
- Summerween: The horror film starring Fibre Federal's radio voice actor, Clint, as a killer clown.
Read the transcript:
Katie:
Welcome to another episode of the Remarkable Credit Union podcast. We created our podcast to help credit union leaders think outside of the box about marketing, technology, and community impact. The Remarkable Credit Union is brought to you by PixelSpoke, an employee-owned cooperative that works with credit unions to create user-friendly, high-converting, award-winning websites. Each episode we bring on expert guests from the credit union and broader cooperative movement for conversations about the intersection of marketing and social impact.
Our goal is to challenge your preconceptions about business as usual and provide you with actionable takeaways that you can use to grow your membership, improve the financial health of your cooperative, and better serve your community. I'm Katie Stone, CEO and one of the co-owners at PixelSpoke.
Kerala:
I'm Kerala Goodkin, also a co-owner at PixelSpoke and the director of marketing and impact. Today, we're going to tackle our big question, why should member reviews be a critical focus for credit unions, and what is the danger of failing to build a strategy around reputation management? To help us answer this question, we're so happy to welcome Heather Snyder. She's the VP of marketing and community development at Fibre Federal Credit Union. She has worked there for almost 14 years and has also worked at or with credit unions since 1991, so long time in the industry.
Very recently, she won Fibre's 2026 Leader of the Year Award. Heather and her husband, Rod, who's also a credit union exec, are obsessed with world travel. Heather has a blog called Travel with the Snyders, which I'm excited to check out. When she's at home, she's an avid baker and is dabbling in going pros. If you need a baker for your wedding or a party, hit her up. Heather, we're so excited to have you today.
Heather:
Thank you so much, Kerala.
Kerala:
Just to start, when I think of reputation management, it sounds like damage control to me, mitigating and responding to bad reviews. But at Fibre, you've really taken it on as an intentional strategy. I'm just curious, what sparked this? What inspired you to focus on member reviews?
Heather:
Well, at first our reviews, they were scattered, they were meager, and frankly, they were pretty brutal. Until about October of 2021, Eltropy, our text provider, presented us with a solution. It was text-based, employee-initiated, and it was focused on Google reviews. Their proposal was that this is not just about gaining your members' trust or improving your ratings, but improving your search rankings, which is what this is all about. The more ratings you have, the more reviews you have, the higher you're going to show up when somebody is Googling you.
To prove their return on investment, our return on investment, they projected a 0.1% additional new members. If we achieved that, we would receive our ROI in 80 days, so pretty impressive. Based on that, we're like, "Okay, we got this." We also had the bandwidth because at that time we had just hired our new marketing manager and she's a ball of fire. She just took this by the reins and just completely made it into this amazing campaign. The first part, and I have to say the hardest part, was claiming our Google Business pages.
If you don't claim them, anyone can make one for you, anyone out in the public, and you're just trying to reign it all in and tell Google Business, "No, actually this is ours. Let's prove that this is ours and consolidate them if needed." There could be three or four of them out there. Some of our departments that we wish to have reviewed don't have a public address and those are extra hard to claim, because Google Business will mail a postcard to that location and somebody at that location needs to know what this postcard is and the importance of this postcard.
Even if we're a big credit union, they don't necessarily know what we're trying to do, and that has to make its way into our hands so we can reply. Once we got that under control and that was massive, it was pretty easy from then on. Since we started, we've seen our average score jump from 3.39 to 4.65 where it is today. We saw an improvement at every one of our 20 locations. Just for an example of what that means to have that improved rating, just over the last weekend, I went to Google and I looked for credit union in Longview, Washington, which is where we're headquartered.
Fibre's going to come up first. We have 4.8 stars with 1,900 reviews. Our main competition in town came up second with 3.8 stars and 173 reviews. That's the difference just a little reputation management can make. We have by far a better rating and about 10 times more reviews than our competition in every single city in which we have a branch.
Katie:
That's quite impressive.
Kerala:
Really impressive. I think a lot of credit unions pride themselves on exceptional member service, and I feel like there's this hope or assumption out there that happy members will just leave reviews on their own. I'm curious, you've touched on this a little bit, but what advice would you give credit unions who are taking a more passive approach?
Heather:
It's not exactly easy to leave a Google review for somebody. You have to log into your Google account and happy members usually are not going to take it upon themselves to look up a branch location and leave a review. Usually, it's only the very unhappy ones. Sometimes these people are not even members of the credit union. That's how it used to be for us.
Kerala:
Yeah. I think about my own experience and I have left some Google reviews and they've all either been one star reviews when I was really unhappy, or they've been five star reviews for companies that took the time to ask me. They're genuine reviews, but I probably would not have done it if they hadn't asked.
Heather:
They took the time to ask you. That's the big difference.
Katie:
I was going to say the same thing. I've only left a handful of reviews, and you're right, there is a high barrier to entry just being able to leave that review. But when someone's taken the time to ask me for a review and I've been satisfied, it's definitely worthwhile to take that time, but it takes that prompting to get a lot of people to take action. Speaking of which, I'd love to get into the nuts and bolts of this. What steps did you take? How did you go about soliciting more reviews from your members? I'm particularly curious to know if there were any concerns about "rigging the system" so to speak. If so, how did you address those concerns?
Heather:
Right. Well, internally we brand it as raving fans, and so staff can choose to solicit a review upon completion of a transaction. We want that staff member to feel like, "Oh, you know what? That was a really good transaction. I feel good about this. I feel like they're happy, I'm happy. Then, my name's Heather. If you'd like to leave a review for me, I can text you the link to my specific location and I would really appreciate it." That's how it goes. It's completely up to the staff to decide how often they want to do that and when they feel comfortable doing that.
Then the managers, this is all public information, they can go to our Google Business page as anyone can and see those reviews for themselves. That's how managers are tracking things on their end. When they see a good review, they love to share it internally with all staff. "Look at this review this staff member got." If a staff member is mentioned by name, they'll receive what we call a star buck. You earn 40 star bucks and you get a day off at work. Staff is highly motivated to get these star bucks. During our all staff training day, we give an award for the staff member who received the most reviews.
This year's winner, just last month, she had received 574 reviews in one year. Just absolutely amazing. We use those reviews everywhere. We put them on our website, we use them in social media, and we even have this amazing way that we can transfer good reviews automatically to our lobby screens. If they're like four or five stars and we can tell them, okay, they're saying nice things, it just goes straight on our lobby screen. That's pretty fun too. We have not had any concerns about rigging the system. These are our real members.
It's not like we're making them up, and it's just commonly accepted as, Katie, you alluded to, that businesses will ask for reviews.
Katie:
Yeah, that's great. I also love the fact that you text them the link. That's I think the easiest way for most people to leave a review. Make it as easy as possible. You shared a lot of numbers there, a lot of impressive numbers, by the way. Would love to hear how did you set up to measure success for your member review initiative? What metrics are you looking at on a regular basis?
Heather:
Well, we do measure staff participation, as you can tell, so we can reward our staff if they're doing a really good job of it. We measure the number of reviews and ratings for each location department just to make sure that they're continually improving. We research our search visibility, as I just shared with you, I did over the weekend, and our scores by every location.
Kerala:
I'm curious if there are any surprising results, it could be positive or negative, but just something that happened as a result of putting more focus on this that you didn't entirely expect.
Heather:
Oh, so many things, Kerala. We started this from a marketing perspective. We wanted to get new members in the door. That was our main motivation. But what surprised us was how, and it shouldn't have surprised us, but we just didn't really think of it from the staff perspective, but the staff embraced it. The staff is so excited about it. They just think it's the most wonderful thing that they can get this recognition for a job well done, and managers love it. As it turned out, it ended up being this amazing treasure trove of member comments that we use for content for an ad campaign. Who even ever thought of that?
That was an amazing and surprising result. The most surprising result was a Killer Clown. Nobody was more surprised about the Killer Clown than I was, and more to come on that.
Katie:
Okay. That's a cool hanger for sure.
Kerala:
Yes.
Heather:
It's a new development. Yes.
Katie:
I look forward to hearing about that.
Kerala:
Yeah.
Katie:
I suspect you could use a lot of those reviews as testimonials on your website too. I bet there are a lot of ways you can easily-
Heather:
100%, yes.
Katie:
Great. Before we get into the Killer Clown, I think it's safe to assume that every credit union, every business, is going to get some critical reviews. What's your process for responding publicly? Do you do that? Is there a backend process for addressing concerns that are raised in critical reviews? How do you address any negative feedback that you're getting?
Heather:
Yeah, it was hard for us to stay on top of all of those responses to reviews, especially if they were negative, for our small marketing team. All of this does still reside within the marketing team, even though it's become such a retail experience. But we did just retain the services of a company called Reviews UP, and they have helped us a ton. They help a lot of other credit unions too. They can now leave the reviews for us and do it in a more timely and thoughtful way, like making all of the responses a little bit different so it doesn't always look like we're robotically leaving responses.
Reviews UP also gives us a generic platform, since 40% of people don't have a Google account. They can't leave a Google review if they wanted to unless they go set up an account. It gives them that generic option, which still improves our search ratings even though it's not with Google. That's helpful too. But at the end of the day, if we have a really critical review, that's sent straight to the manager of that location or department so they can follow up directly. Oftentimes, our members will revise or remove a negative review after we've reached out to them.
Once they realize we're truly listening to them and we're truly trying to solve their problems, it can turn into a positive experience for them.
Kerala:
That's great to hear. I just feel like companies can be under fire now. It seems like people can say anything online and it's hard to maybe not get too defensive, but also respond authentically to those more critical reviews.
Heather:
You can ask Google Business to remove reviews that are inappropriate that are just completely untrue.
Kerala:
Absolutely.
Heather:
They have done that for us as well.
Kerala:
Great. The reason I learned about your member review initiative was because you presented at the recent MAC conference in Arizona and you were a runner up for the very prestigious MACQUEE Award, which basically means I think we got over 500 award submissions. I used to serve on the Mac board and yours was in the top four. You weren't specifically presenting about your member review strategy, but about a campaign that followed it to get more leverage out of all your positive reviews. I will be including some links to this campaign in the show notes when we release this podcast because you really have to experience some of these videos for yourself.
But Heather, I'm curious if you can just tell our listeners a bit about this campaign and how it came to be.
Heather:
Well, we were looking to create some new television ads and we wanted to be just completely different in our marketplace, something that others... As you know, we're in the Portland area market with you, how many credit unions and financial institutions are on TV. We wanted to cut through that clutter and do something different. We really wanted to use our own members in some ads, but trying to pull members together was just, we realized, okay, we're hitting a brick wall with this. We need to think in a different direction.
That's when we were like, oh, my gosh, we have these thousands of member reviews. We are sitting on a whole treasure trove of content that we hadn't really considered. Then when blue skying, how are we going to deliver that content? We thought about Clint. Clint is our radio guy. He's been our guy on the radio for years. He has just an unmistakable, just beautiful voice for radio. He's always able to deliver our ads in a sarcastic and fun way, just a little bit tweaked so it's ironic. We like using him and we reached out to him. We said, "Clint, have you done any video?" He's like, "No, I've never done video before." We're like, "But would you be interested?"
He's like, "I don't know." In spite of how his voice sounds, he's the most unassuming and self-deprecating person. Trying to work with him, we're like, "No, I think you could do this, Clint." We flew him up to our recording studio and he was just absolutely perfect. We're like, "You mean to tell me you've not done video before?" Because he was so, so good. Listeners, please go check out the links because I can't do it justice. We dressed him up like, if you're familiar with the Masterpiece Theater, even if you're not, he's still funny. It was just adorable the way that he reads our actual member reviews.
I was just working with Clint last week on a radio ad that he's doing for us that's coming up. I'm like, "Clint, we've won some amazing awards for you. You're just practically a star in the credit union world." He's like, "Oh, I just can't even believe that. That's just crazy." I'm like, "Well, since you were on video now, have you done more with it?" He goes, "Well, yeah, I actually have. I'm starring in this movie now about a killer clown." I'm like, "Okay, Clint, I know you're pulling my leg. What's going on?" He's like, "Yeah, well." Because everything he says is understated.
I'm like, "If I went to IMDB right now and I looked at Clint, I would see you on there as a killer clown." He's like, "Yeah." I'm with my phone just during the call. I'm like, "Oh, my gosh, Clint, are you kidding me? There you are. He has four movie credits now." He's like, "Yeah." He's like, "This is all because I did this video for you guys. You guys gave me the confidence to just put myself out there." He put himself out there in a scary way. It's like, this is not the Clint we know. He's a lot of things. He's funny, but he's not scary. But oh my gosh, if you want to look up the movie Summerween, available for streaming, there's Clint, just scary as can be.
He doesn't have a lot of lines, which is ironic for a person who speaks for a living, but it's very scary and he absolutely steals the show as the main character.
Katie:
Well, I cannot wait for him to win his Oscar and to shout out you all and give all the thanks to Fibre for kicking off his career.
Heather:
We gave him his start.
Kerala:
Yes. Absolutely. I would say that. Yeah, definitely an unintended consequence of this.
Heather:
If we had not gone down the path of reputation management, there would not be a killer clown, and that's a fact.
Katie:
That's great. That's great.
Kerala:
I think the next challenge is integrating a killer clown into your next marketing campaign, maybe Halloween next year.
Heather:
I think that's necessary.
Katie:
A crossover event kind of. Yeah. All right. Well, it is time now for some rapid fire questions. My first one, as an avid traveler, I would love to know what's the best trip you've ever taken?
Heather:
I would have to say it was in 2022 when my husband and I took a Mediterranean cruise from Barcelona to Venice. That was so special to me because I had never traveled outside of North America up to that point. Marriage and children and career came first. Once the kids were getting older, we're like, our 25th wedding anniversary, we want to do it. We want to do it big. We want to make the biggest two-week cruise there ever was. We're going to go from zero to hero with our world travel just right off the bat. The cruise line made us pay 18 months in advance.
We're all set to go. Well, our 25th anniversary was April of 2020, so that did not happen. Then so, "Okay, 26th anniversary, here we come." No, it still was not going to happen. And so 2022, we finally got to go, and I was just practically in tears going to the airport. This cruise line has had our money for five years now and we're finally going on the cruise. We had the best time because we had just looked forward to it for so long.
Kerala:
I bet. Anticipation sounds like a beautiful part of the world to explore.
Heather:
Oh, it was. It sure was.
Katie:
I will say better to have missed it all together than to have been on a cruise in April.
Heather:
Totally.
Katie:
My parents were actually on a cruise ship when the pandemic hit, so that was a bit stressful.
Heather:
Oh, wow.
Katie:
Yeah.
Kerala:
I remember that.
Heather:
Yes.
Katie:
All right. Next rapid-fire question. What is your go-to comfort food?
Heather:
Never really understood the word comfort attached with food, and I might be in the minority about that, but my favorite go-to food, if I'm eating out, is tacos every time. Love them.
Katie:
Yeah, can't go wrong.
Heather:
Any way I can get them.
Kerala:
I think tacos qualifies as comfort food, for sure.
Katie:
Oh, yeah.
Heather:
Oh, okay. All right.
Katie:
Yes. Finally, if you could instantly become an expert in something, what would that be?
Heather:
I've really struggled with this question because I'm so curious about a million different topics. I asked ChatGPT what ChatGPT thought, and it was like, "Well, Heather," it had all these ideas, but he said, "really, at the end of it should be art history, especially architecture." It's true because I'm always like, when I'm traveling and looking at historic buildings, or even we have a lot of historic homes in our own city, and I'll be like, "What am I looking at? Is this art deco or is it Art Nouveau? What's the difference?" Just the different styles. It's so interesting to me to understand, where did this come from? Why does it look like that?
That's what I would say. I've laughed like I need flashcards to remind myself of the different styles, but yeah, so I'm sure that's why ChatGPT said, "Yup, Heather, that's for you."
Katie:
That's great.
Kerala:
I love using ChatGPT to get to know yourself better.
Heather:
Yeah, I recommend anyone try that because it's like, wow, you've really been listening to all my questions.
Kerala:
A little creepy, but maybe.
Heather:
Right.
Kerala:
All right. Well, let's do our final take. Just as a reminder, our big question today was, why should member reviews be a critical focus for credit unions and what is the danger of failing to build a strategy around reputation management? Definitely already touched on this, but I'm just curious, Heather, in a few sentences, can you summarize your thoughts on this?
Heather:
Yes. Google Business says 91% of consumers use reviews to evaluate local businesses, which in theory means that based on our number of reviews and ratings and the fact that we're served up first, prospective members would choose us over the competition in every town we serve. In mid-size credit unions like ours, we're only seeing 2.2% annual net membership growth right now. It's particularly hard for us because we serve rural areas and they're not growing, and in some cases they're shrinking. While we're maintaining growth, we're barely doing it.
It's really imperative that we continue to prioritize membership growth strategies like managing our member reviews. Frankly, I can't think of anything more important for credit unions to do from a marketing perspective than taking control over our own narrative.
Katie:
Well said.
Kerala:
That was beautifully put. Thank you. I hope you'll inspire some more credit unions to put some focus on this. The ROI just seems incredibly clear to me and all things considered, it doesn't seem like a huge lift. Definitely a sizable one, but doable.
Heather:
Definitely.
Kerala:
Yeah. Wonderful. Well, thanks so much for joining us today, Heather.
Katie:
Yeah, thank you.
Heather:
Thank you for inviting me.
Kerala:
Let's think about some key takeaways here. I think first and foremost, it's very obvious to me after this conversation that all credit unions should be pursuing a proactive reputation management strategy if they aren't already. It is a low-hanging fruit with very high and tangible ROI. We know your member service is exceptional, but it's pretty clear that most members are unlikely to leave a review unless they're explicitly asked. The numbers from Fibre Federal are pretty eye-opening. By actively soliciting Google reviews, they saw their average rating jump from 3.39 stars, Heather said, to 4.65 stars across their 20 locations.
That significantly outperformed their local competitors, both in review volume and very crucially in search visibility. Secondly, perhaps an unintended benefit, or more surprising benefit, is how empowering frontline employees to request reviews can improve team morale. I love that member reviews help make frontline employees' vital contributions visible across the credit union, and they also help to engage and reward member-facing staff. As a somewhat competitive person myself, I appreciated the element of friendly competition via star bucks, not coffee, but bucks for stars that employees could accumulate for extra time off.
It seemed to really help them go the extra mile and inspire more enthusiastic participation. Lastly, member reviews on Google are very beneficial, but they can also be leveraged far beyond Google and repurposed in a lot of creative ways. I just love how Fibre Federal creatively leveraged their review repository to create these award-winning video ads that are both highly entertaining, but also so authentic. There's nothing better than letting members speak on the credit union's behalf. All right. Well, thanks for joining us today for another great episode.
The Remarkable Credit Union is brought to you by PixelSpoke, an employee-owned cooperative that works with credit unions to create user-friendly, high-converting, award-winning websites. You can learn more and check out our work at pixelspoke.coop. That's pixelspoke, all one word, dot C-O-O-P. Until next time, I wish you the best of luck in making your credit union remarkable.