PixelSpoke Blog

Trust Before Tactics: Lessons in Financial Inclusion from Three Credit Unions

Written by Kerala Goodkin | Nov 17, 2026, 12:31:56 AM

When it comes to financial inclusion, there is good news and bad news. On the good news front, the FDIC’s 2023 household survey found that a record low of 4.2 percent of households lacked a bank or credit union account. This is roughly half the 2011 peak of 8.2 percent.

The bad news? Stubborn gaps persist. Black households (10.6 percent) and Hispanic households (9.5 percent) are unbanked at several times the rate of white households (1.9 percent). Among the reasons cited for staying outside the system, “don’t trust banks” ranks second, behind minimum balance requirements.

Credit unions already offer many deposit products with no minimum balance requirements, and the balance required to open an account is typically $5, sometimes with an ongoing balance requirement as low as $1.

Lack of trust, on the other hand, is a much thornier problem. Trust is built through relationships, and relationships can’t be launched with a campaign. Three recent conversations on PixelSpoke’s The Remarkable Credit Union podcast reveal what the process of building mutually trustworthy relationships actually looks like in practice. We talked to Christin Vaughn of Allegiance Credit Union in Oklahoma, Cindy Shogry-Raimer of Greylock Federal Credit Union in Massachusetts, and Jordan Baehr of Monroe Community Credit Union in Michigan.

The communities they serve are unique, but their approaches to building trust share the same core philosophy. Vaughn captures it in a mantra she picked up in Filene Research Institute’s equity incubator: “Do nothing about me without me.”

Sounds catchy, but what does it mean, exactly? Here are four key tenets:

1. Start where the problem is visible, and listen before you build

Inclusion efforts often begin with an assumption about what a community needs, motivated by a desire — whether authentic or purely profit-driven — to reach a new market.

Allegiance Credit Union’s efforts began with a complaint. Its own employees brought up that their family and friends couldn’t bank there because the credit union didn’t accept ITINs, the tax identification numbers many non-citizen residents use. “That’s honestly what woke us up,” Vaughn said. Allegiance proceeded to commission demographic research and spend years in community meetings and small-group conversations.

What surfaced went far beyond identification or language barriers. There was a distinct lack of trust in U.S. financial systems, as well as a fear of navigating them. At the same time, community members voiced aspirations around homeownership, business ownership, and generational wealth.

Greylock Credit Union’s Community Development Advisory Committee surfaced a critical insight when a member asked whether staff realized that the word “credit” carries negative associations in Black and brown communities. Shogry-Raimer admitted she hadn’t been aware of this, and this awareness helped inform how they talk about their institution and their products in these communities.

As Innovation Manager at Monroe Community Credit Union, Jordan Baehr describes his role primarily as someone who breaks down siloes to help solve problems. He says, "Innovation isn't about having the newest technology. It's really about people being willing to solve problems. The most innovative organizations aren't necessarily the ones with the biggest budgets or the latest tools. They're the ones with the employees who feel empowered to identify challenges, take on ownership of those challenges, and work toward better solutions."

2. Share real decision-making power, not just a chance to comment

Consultation and co-creation are two different things. Asking for feedback isn’t a bad thing, but how many of us have filled out surveys, only to be left wondering if anyone ever read our responses or if anything came of what we suggested? A credit union can’t co-create with everybody, but there are meaningful ways they can involve prospects and members. Native Women Lead, a partner of Filene’s Racial Economic Equity Incubator, frames the goal as “building the table with the community.”

Allegiance went furthest, building Alianza Credit Union — a distinct brand, website, and branch serving the Hispanic community. This project involved enlisting a group of roughly 100 residents who called themselves the Centuriones, who worked with a local creative agency. They chose the colors, imagery, and copy, and they named the brand. Vaughn sat in as “a fly on the wall” and had no say over the visuals, which she called “a real practice in relinquishing control.” Day to day, she still defers to her bilingual marketing coordinator and branch staff, because she lacks the lived experience to represent the brand herself.

Greylock’s aforementioned Community Development Advisory Committee shows how to make that power durable. It began as quarterly restaurant dinners with four Greylock staff, including the CEO, and community members spanning race, ability, and generation, with “no rules.” It has since added members representing LGBTQIA, veteran, and elderly communities, adopted a mission statement and minutes, and created a position for a board liaison, who delivers the notes to the full board. The feedback arrives raw, not “sanitized,” Shogry-Raimer says, and it isn’t always comfortable. Her advice: “Get comfortable with being uncomfortable.”

It’s important to remember that your team members are part of your community, too. Baehr started as a teller at Monroe Community Credit Union, has held seven roles, and believes “people are usually trying to do the right thing,” but they see problems only from their own seat. He argues that the biggest untapped opportunity in credit unions is letting employees act on ideas they already have — especially those who are closest to the communities they serve. When Baehr found the paper-based financial reality fair for local high schoolers clunky, particularly for an audience accustomed to using their phones, he taught himself to build an app.

Internally, employees at credit unions often don’t feel empowered to make meaningful change. Like so many legacy organizations, credit unions often divide roles into “thinkers” and “doers,” with the thinkers holding the bulk of the decision-making power. But ironically, these thinkers often sit the furthest away from the frontlines. Meanwhile, the doers, who are talking regularly to members, find themselves with very little recourse to act on the problems that these members are surfacing for them.

The logic here is clear: the person closest to the friction should help design the fix.

3. Let evidence challenge your assumptions, and build the infrastructure before the marketing

Good intentions are a good start, but you cannot measure success on good intentions alone. Greylock has long been the leading mortgage lender in its county and over-performed on nearly every homeownership measure, with one glaring exception: applications from Black borrowers. Years of outreach didn’t close the gap, so Greylock commissioned a redlining report. It found that redlining had been prevalent in Pittsfield and that its damage, including eroded trust, persisted.

Released in 2022 in partnership with the NAACP, the report has since been used by municipal leaders, nonprofits, and the local board of Realtors. Greylock also tracks HMDA lending data against local demographics and has had policies reviewed for implicit bias. “You want your stories, but you want your statistics,” Shogry-Raimer says.

The cost of not looking can be steep. In 2024, the Department of Justice announced a settlement of more than $6.5 million with Citadel Federal Credit Union, its first redlining resolution involving a credit union. The complaint alleged that from 2017 through 2021 Citadel discouraged applications from, and failed to serve, majority-Black and Hispanic neighborhoods around Philadelphia. Citadel disagreed with the allegations while acknowledging shortcomings in reaching those neighborhoods. The remedies, including new branches, a community lending officer, and a community credit needs assessment, echo what Greylock and Allegiance undertook proactively and voluntarily. Citadel had to scramble to rebuild trust, while Greylock and Allegiance set out to build trust from the start.

Evidence also reveals where marketing is premature. Vaughn is emphatic about “infrastructure first.” Before launching any marketing campaign, Allegiance changed policies to accept ITINs and the Mexican Matrícula ID, earned Inclusiv’s Juntos Avanzamos designation, translated documents and systems, added a Spanish phone tree, and set hours around community members’ work schedules. Greylock lent to ITIN holders like any other borrower, then added community lending products with no PMI, lower credit-score and down-payment requirements, and paired coaching once research showed entry barriers.

4. Commit for the long haul, and stay willing to be wrong

In a landscape that prioritizes efficiency, productivity, and short-term success metrics, it can be difficult to commit to the slow, messy work of community building. Allegiance began its work in 2020, developed the Alianza brand in 2022 and 2023, opened a modular branch in 2025, and plans a permanent building in 2027, a process Vaughn calls “five-plus years in the making.”

Their patience and commitment to laying a strong foundation paid off. Forty-five percent of accounts opened in the first ten months came from referrals, a proxy for trust, and Alianza accounted for 57 percent of all new Allegiance members in 2025.

Commitment doesn’t mean getting it right the first time. Alianza’s modular building initially carried only Alianza branding, and passersby asked whether it was a restaurant. Vaughn’s team worried it looked like a “fly-by-night” operation, so they added Allegiance’s logo and “Since 1963” to signal stability. The brands, she concluded, needed to be “more blended than we originally thought.” The commitment stayed fixed while the execution evolved.

Baehr offers a complementary test for long-term viability: a solution that works only because one person holds it together isn’t sustainable. Lasting progress means systems that are “understandable, repeatable, and scalable.” They also need to be flexible, with built-in space to evolve over time. As credit unions grow, the tendency is often to become more rigid about processes and procedures. But this only hampers innovation and results in siloed solutions that become less and less effective over time.

Final Thoughts

We know distrust keeps millions of households unbanked and underbanked, but trust-building doesn’t come with a one-size-fits-all blueprint. That said, there are some best practices you can follow: find the problem where people actually feel it, give community members and frontline staff real authority, test your assumptions against data and qualitative feedback, build the infrastructure before the megaphone, and never stop listening and evolving.

True financial inclusion will never be about a single product or marketing campaign. It may feel daunting, but Vaughn advises: “You will never feel fully ready.” Starting small beats never starting at all.

This article originally appeared on CUInsight.com.